1954/55Lolly DebattistaFloriana
1955/56Tony NichollSliema Wanderers
1956/57Joe BonniciSliema Wanderers
1957/58Joe CiliaValletta
1958/59Alfred Vella JamesFloriana
1959/60Louis TheobaldHibernians
1960/61Joe ZammitValletta
1961/62Lolly BorgFloriana
1962/63Edwin SchembriValletta
1963/64Joe CiliaValletta
1964/65Not Awarded 
1965/66Ronnie CocksSliema Wanderers
1966/67Eddie TheobaldHibernians
1967/68Alfred DebonoFloriana
1968/69John PriviteraHibernians
1969/70Joe CiniSliema Wanderers
1970/71Eddie TheobaldHibernians
1971/72Edward DarmaninSliema Wanderers
1972/73Freddie DebonoValletta
1973/74Willie VassalloFloriana
1974/75Eddie VellaValletta
1975/76John HollandFloriana
1976/77Raymond XuerebFloriana
1977/78John HollandFloriana
1978/79Guzi XuerebHibernians
1979/80Norman ButtigiegHibernians
1980/81Leli FabriSliema Wanderers
1981/82Ernest Spiteri GonziHibernians
1982/83Carmel BusuttilRabat Ajax
1983/84Charles MuscatZurrieq
1984/85Leonard FarrugiaValletta
1985/86Carmel BusuttilRabat Ajax
1986/87Raymond VellaHamrun Spartans
1987/88John ButtigiegSliema Wanderers
1988/89Charles ScerriHibernians
1989/90Michael DegorgioHamrun Spartans
1990/91Raymond VellaHamrun Spartans
1991/92Nicky SalibaValletta
1992/93Joe BrincatHamrun Spartans
1993/94Silvio VellaRabat Ajax
1994/95Michael WoodsHibernians
1995/96Noel TurnerSliema Wanderers
1996/97Gilbert AgiusValletta
1997/98Mario MuscatHibernians
1998/99Nicky SalibaValletta
1999/2000Ernest BarrySliema Wanderers
2000/01Gilbert AgiusValletta
2001/02Adrian MifsudHibernians
2002/03Noel TurnerSliema Wanderers
2003/04Stefan GiglioSliema Wanderers
2004/05Andrew CohenHibernians
2005/06Andrew CohenHibernians
2006/07Gilbert AgiusValletta
2007/08Kevin SammutMarsaxlokk
2008/09Clayton FaillaHibernians
2009/10Shaun BajadaBirkirkara
2010/11Roderick BriffaValletta
2011/12Clayton FaillaHibernians
2012/13Paul FenechBirkirkara
2013/14Ryan FenechValletta
2014/15Andrew CohenHibernians
2015/16Roderick BriffaValletta
2016/17Bjorn KristensenHibernians
2017/18Andrew CohenGzira United
2018/19Andrei AgiusHibernians